The Art of Fielding

I know nothing about baseball. Nothing. For this book I had to look up what a shortstop is, how many bases there are and why the field is called a diamond. Well, they say there is a first time for everything.

Despite my ignorance I spent many happy hours working my way through the dozens of games Henry Skrimshander and his teammates play. Why? Because of the parts in between.

I love books that teach me something about how the world works. That show me authentic human relationships and make somewhat dramatic but very relatable statements about the struggles of trying to live a fulfilling life. And this book does exactly that. We follow the lives of four different people:

  • Henry, who is recruited as a short stop for Westish College because of his amazing track record of flawless games suddenly becomes too nervous to play.
  • Mike Schwartz, the senior who recruited him, struggles with the difference between being a good coach and being a good player.
  • Guert Affenlight, the director of the college and a proclaimed bachelor, suddenly finds himself falling for one of his students.
  • Pella Affenlight, Guert’s daughter, decides to escape her marriage by returning to Westish and is confronted with the emptiness of her life.

As the novel progresses the stories of these people intertwine further and further. They help each other confront their anxieties, push each other to consider their dreams and find the limits to their ambitions. I appreciated how the novel is not only about working towards your dreams, but also about finding out whether you are really ready to take a next step. Moreover, its also acknowledges that even if you are a successful sixty-something college professor, you can still discover new things about yourself.


Although I could have done with fewer blow-by-blow accounts of the Westish baseball games, reading about life as a college baseball player was very interesting for me. This is most probably something I will never experience, so it was interesting to learn about the team sport culture and how it defines Henry & Schwartz’ identity so completely. A lot of the wisdoms about playing Baseball seem transferable, and are indeed applied to Guert and Pella’s stories to tie the novel together.

I often dislike romances between teachers and students, but Guert’s is actually very interesting. Partly this is because he is discovering his own bisexuality, and I do wonder whether I would have disliked him more if he had fallen for a younger girl. However, it is also because the power in this relationship is very clearly in the hands of the student that the relationship feels healthier. Many of his observations about love are just so cúte.

The writing is occasionally flowery but never cliché and contrasts the fast paced short sentences of the baseball scenes very nicely. The novel even gets a bit meta sometimes:

“She’s been reading too much, he thought—had drifted across that line that separated what you might find in a book from what you might do.”

Both Guert and Pella love Moby Dick. In fact, in one of the best introductory chapters ever written (I think) we learn that Guert’s main claim to fame as an academic is finding a manuscript revealing that Herman Melville once visited Westish to give a lecture. Subsequently, a large statue of Melville is erected in front of the school and its baseball team is re-named ‘the Harpooners’. Guert even has a tattoo of a whale in Melville’s honour and the book is full of references to him.

“It was easy enough to write a sentence, but if you were going to create a work of art, the way Melville had, each sentence needed to fit perfectly with the one that preceded it, and the unwritten one that would follow.”

Personally, I really love it when a novel pays homage to a literary classic so this was right up my street. I’ve never actually read Moby Dick (one of my friends scared me off with its apparently endless instructions on how to build a boat) but The Art of Fielding has definitely got me interested…

What do you think? Have you read The Art of Fielding and are you into baseball or not? And, more importantly, should I try Moby Dick?

9 thoughts on “Book | The Art of Fielding by Chad Harbach

  1. Great review, I’ll give it a try when I have the chance to!

    As for Moby Dick, I haven’t read it myself, but I believe you should try it.
    I’ve read Robinson Crusoe before, and boy, it’s filled with instructions of farming, constructing a Hut, gates, making sandals, and many other exhausting descriptions. It’s boring during those parts, but I made it through.

    The thing is, even though there are lots of boring, technical bits, they provide you a glimpse on how hard it is to build these things. When you have a rough idea of it, you’ll be able to relate more to the characters, and that makes the interesting parts richer.

    So, yeah, give it a chance 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I listened to this one on audiobook, and it was definitely fascinating. I agree that the relationship in the book was totally in the hands of the student — it was an almost surreal (word choice?) set of circumstances.

    As far as the baseball bits, I absolutely loved all that. Of course, I’m a big baseball fan, which is what drew me to the book to begin with.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.